David McArthur
The last time I saw my father, the sun hadn’t fully risen and the streets of north Hammond were still struggling to shake off the frost. I was driving to my job at an aluminum mill for my day shift, the road empty except for a man on the shoulder ahead of me. He walked against traffic, arguing with the wind—arms slicing the air, body jerking in sharp, frantic bursts.
I eased off the accelerator as I approached, not yet understanding why he held my attention. His jacket was stained and frayed at the cuffs; his jeans sagged low, begging for a belt. His hair stood up in clumps, matted into uneven spikes as if he’d slept on concrete. Even with the windows up, I could feel the intensity of whatever he was yelling. His mouth moved fast, each word shaped toward someone who wasn’t there.
Then I recognized him.
It was Gordon—my father.
His hands clamped over his ears, his face contorting as if he could shake loose whatever was inside. He spun toward a billboard towering over the street and shouted again. As my truck passed, he turned his head toward me. His eyes skimmed across the windshield and bounced away, unfocused, not landing anywhere at all.
My foot hovered over the brake. I could have pulled over, rolled the window down, called his name. I could have asked if he needed help, or simply stood beside him long enough for both of us to recognize something familiar in each other.
But my hands tightened on the wheel. The truck kept moving.
In the rearview mirror, he shrank quickly—first into a figure, then a smudge, then nothing. Just another troubled man yelling at ghosts on a road where most people didn’t bother to look twice.
I didn’t stop. I drove on.
***
Years earlier, before he vanished into that version of himself, Gordon was an occasional voice on the phone. Not a presence, not a parent—just a voice arriving in short, erratic bursts, usually when I was folding laundry or cooking dinner. The ring would cut through my little apartment, sharp and urgent, and when I picked up, I’d hear his breath first. Quick, uneven, like he’d sprinted to the receiver.
“David, you there?” he’d ask.
“Yeah. What’s up?”
Gordon never allowed silence to settle. He filled every gap with warnings or conspiracies—men at the mill who wanted him dead, threats closing in around him, strangers leaving bullets on his doorstep. Once he whispered, “I can’t talk long. They’re listening.
“Who?” I asked.
“The Chinese,” he said. “Look what they did to the cowboys. The oil companies are behind it all.”
Other times it was neighbors plotting through the walls, or voices traveling through the pipes at night. His stories frayed at the edges, every thread unraveling into another, and another, and another. And yet every so often his tone softened, settling into something almost normal. He asked about my job, about my sister Christy, about whether I was still taking classes. For a minute or two, he sounded like the father I used to know—sharp, curious, restless.
I leaned in during those moments, despite myself, believing maybe he was leveling out.
Then the ground would shift again, and the delusion would swallow him whole.
Hanging up left me with the hollow feeling of having spoken to a stranger wearing my father’s voice.
Eventually, a doctor put a name to what was happening. I didn’t hear it from Gordon; I heard it from my mother. Her voice trembled with something between triumph and desperation, as if naming the illness finally gave her leverage over it.
“They said it’s paranoid schizophrenia,” she told me. “They said if he takes the medication, he’ll be fine.”
“Is he taking it?” I asked.
“He doesn’t believe them. He says the doctors are trying to kill him.”
I believed her at first when she said that the drugs he’d abused for years had caused the madness and the pills might pull him back. Later, talking to people who understood more than we did, I learned it was likely the opposite: the illness had been in him long before the drugs, and the drugs were his attempt to quiet whatever was already breaking loose inside.
After the diagnosis, the phone calls continued for a while, thinning out, scattering. Sometimes they came three nights in a week; sometimes months passed between them. Each call left me bracing for the next, knowing I couldn’t predict the version of Gordon that might show up—angry, frantic, lucid, terrified.
Gordon stopped coming home to Mom. He was too paranoid to stay in the same place more than a few days. She kept waiting.
“Maybe he’ll get better,” she’d say, eyes shining. “He’s off heroin now. He just needs to take his meds.”
Hope was her form of faith; we called it denial. Naming the illness hadn’t given her power over it after all. It had only given her a new script to read from.
***
Christy, my older sister, didn’t believe in waiting on a miracle. Growing up, she had been the one to challenge Gordon—small fists, anything she could grab, always fighting him. Years later, when our family had splintered beyond recognition, she used her voice instead of her fists.
In a rare lucid moment, Gordon appeared at her door. He asked for redemption, for forgiveness. He asked for love.
“If you love me, you’ll go away,” she told him. “Leave. Divorce Mom. Disappear. Don’t ever come back.”
She carried that line with a steadiness I didn’t possess. When she spoke, it wasn’t a threat—it was a directive, and she never wavered. It was the only thing that had gotten through to him in a long time.
He agreed somberly, as if accepting his fate. Christy shut the door, not even watching him drive away.
One evening, after the paperwork settled, I stood outside her house while her kids argued over the TV inside. The noise seeped through the windows, tangled with laughter and bickering, the sound of a new family with different problems.
“Gordon’s gone for good now,” Christy said.
“I know.”
“We can’t tell Mom why.”
“I know that too.”
She didn’t celebrate. She didn’t sigh in relief. She just stated it plainly, the way she always did when something irreversible had happened.
***
In the months after Gordon left, my mother didn’t step into freedom. She collapsed into waiting.
She moved into my sister Sherry’s basement, arranging her small corner of it like a chapel. A recliner against the wall. A Bible on her lap, underlined in places where the promises felt most needed. The letters she wrote stacked beside her like offerings. A dehumidifier hummed in the background, thinning the air with the smell of mildew and dryer sheets.
She wrote to Gordon often—long, looping script on loose pages she folded into envelopes addressed to a post office box he once shared with her. I don’t know if he ever wrote back. If he did, I suspected it was only to ask for money. But even that possibility gave her hope. She would have read every word as if it were a love letter.
***
That morning on that long stretch of north Hammond road stayed with me. Not just because I didn’t stop, but because of what I saw in him in that split second—two men layered over each other like a double exposure.
There was the father of my childhood, the one who dragged me to Lake Michigan with a six-pack, stretching out in the sun while I ran along the beach. The one with the mirrored sunglasses and red hair and ruddy cheeks, the man who turned every task into a lesson about how a real man should move through the world. He was hard and challenging. He was hot-tempered and unfair. But he was strong and smart, and sometimes he was even proud of me.
And then there was the man on the road: clothes hanging off his frame, teeth bared at phantoms, movements jerking so wildly he looked like he was arguing with the sky.
People like to imagine a clear line between who someone was and who they became, but the truth is that those versions live inside one another, overlapping. The man shouting at the billboard was the same one who once taught me chess and never let me win. The man waving his arms in confusion was the same one who had shaped me with equal parts fear, admiration, and longing.
I told myself that stopping wouldn’t have helped. That he wouldn’t have recognized me. That he was too far gone. But beneath the justifications was a simpler truth: I didn’t stop because I no longer knew how to stand in front of him without losing pieces of myself.
Families like ours don’t get clean endings. People unravel, vanish, reappear as shadows of a memory. What survives isn’t always reconciliation; it’s the quiet instinct to step away from the disaster you can’t fix.
As he shrank in the mirror that morning, I realized I wasn’t just driving to work. I was continuing a choice I had been making for years—the choice to protect the small, steady life I’d built from the wreckage of the one I grew up inside.
I didn’t stop. I had already spent too many years learning how to keep going.
#
David McArthur is a writer and general contractor living in Jamul, California. His work explores family, survival, and the complicated ways people try to care for one another, and he is currently finishing a memoir about growing up in Northwest Indiana.